Could $2 million in state funding save Fernandina Beach's youth soccer fields?

Ayscue proposes seeking $2 million in state funding; city manager says commissioners will review property appraisals and the FAA approval process Dec. 1

Posted

FERNANDINA BEACH - Parents, coaches and youth soccer officials filled Fernandina Beach City Hall Tuesday, pleading with the newly seated City Commission to save the Ybor Alvarez soccer fields as Commissioner Darron Ayscue proposed seeking $2 million in state funding to help purchase the property.

The proposal received support during the commission's discussion of its 2027 legislative priorities, opening another potential source of money for a purchase that appeared financially out of reach just two weeks earlier.
 

Ayscue suggested adding recreational land acquisition to the city's requests for 2027 state appropriations, with the Ybor Alvarez soccer fields as the intended beneficiary.

"What if we did seek funds for recreational land purchase?" Ayscue asked. "If we're tight on funds, state appropriations isn't a bad place to go ask."
 

Mayor Genece Minshew asked how much money he had in mind.

"Two million," Ayscue replied.
 

When Minshew asked whether the request would be specifically for Ybor Alvarez, Ayscue said yes, although he acknowledged the Federal Aviation Administration could still refuse to approve the property's sale.

Of course the FAA could tell us no," Ayscue said. "We could secure the funding through the state, the FAA tells us no, the money goes back."
 

The proposed appropriation would supplement the $1.75 million Nassau County has committed toward acquiring the soccer fields. Preliminary appraisals have placed the value of the approximately 11.6-acre property between $2.8 million and $3.5 million.

Ayscue acknowledged that the state funding was far from certain. An appropriation would have to win legislative approval and survive the governor's budget veto process.
 

"It never hurts to ask," he said.

 
Darron Ayscue
Darron Ayscue
 
 

Ayscue also suggested the funding request could be written broadly enough to support the purchase of another soccer facility if acquiring Ybor Alvarez proves impossible.

Commissioner Scott Inglis questioned whether the city should first obtain a written commitment from the FAA that it would allow the property to be purchased.
 

"They're the ones that hold the cards," Inglis said.

City Manager Sarah Campbell explained that the city cannot obtain a definitive answer from the FAA until commissioners formally decide to pursue the acquisition and submit an application.
 

"They will not give us a response until we make a decision and make application," Campbell said.

Campbell told commissioners that the next step is scheduled for Dec. 1, when city staff will present all three property appraisals and outline a possible path toward acquiring the land.
 

"We will be able to present to you all three appraisals and a path forward before you make application to the FAA," Campbell said.

The process leaves the city facing two separate hurdles. Commissioners must decide whether to pursue FAA approval to release the airport property for sale while also securing the money needed to purchase it. Even if the Legislature approves Ayscue's proposed $2 million appropriation, the purchase cannot proceed without FAA approval.
 

Campbell said the Dec. 1 agenda will also include the city's legislative priorities and appropriations requests, allowing commissioners to consider the funding proposal alongside the property appraisals and possible FAA application.

City Grants Administrator Lorelei Jacobs cautioned against making the funding request too narrowly focused on replacing the existing fields because earlier federal and state grants used for Ybor Alvarez carry continuing obligations.
 

Jacobs suggested describing the request more broadly as recreational land acquisition for soccer facilities.

 
Lorelei Jacobs
Lorelei Jacobs
 
 
She also identified the Florida Recreation Development Assistance Program as another possible source of funding. That program could provide $200,000 toward recreational land acquisition but would require a $200,000 local match.
 

Minshew indicated that commissioners supported adding recreational land acquisition to the city's legislative priorities.

"I think you have the direction you need to add that to our priorities," she said.
 

The discussion represented a change from the Nov. 4 commission workshop, when a majority of the previous commission concluded the city could not afford to purchase the property, particularly with anticipated property tax revenue losses resulting from voter approval of Amendment 3.

At that workshop, then-Mayor James Antun said he saw no financial path forward despite his personal desire to preserve the fields, where his daughter plays soccer.
 

The newly seated commission now faces the challenge of determining whether state funding, the county's financial commitment and other available resources can make the purchase possible.

The emotional weight of the issue became clear during Tuesday's public comments.
 

Speaker after speaker described Ybor Alvarez as more than a collection of soccer fields. They warned that losing the complex would affect hundreds of children and place additional pressure on other youth sports programs already competing for limited recreational space.

Andy Francis, a longtime leader in Amelia Island youth soccer, told commissioners the city could not afford to lose the facility.
 

"We got to give these kids place to play," Francis said. "Honestly, our city can't, they can't afford to lose Ybor Alvarez."

Francis said the soccer program has served the community for decades and provides children with friendships, mentoring and a sense of belonging.
 

He pointed to the existing infrastructure at Ybor Alvarez, including lighting, parking, bathrooms and storage facilities, as advantages that would be difficult and expensive to replace.

"Purchasing Ybor is not just about the 800 families that are currently registered there," Francis said. "It's about all the families in the future that are going to need that program."
 

Francis said the county's financial commitment provides an opportunity for the city to secure the property if it can find the remaining funding.

Caitlin Lundry, a fourth-grade teacher, soccer coach and vice president of the youth soccer league, spoke about growing up playing on the same fields where her children now compete.
 

"I actually grew up playing on those fields," Lundry said. "I was my daughter's age when I started, and it means so much to my heart and my soul to see my children out there playing on the same exact fields that I grew up playing on."

Lundry warned that moving soccer programs to multiple locations could make participation more difficult for working families.
 

Parents already struggle to coordinate jobs, school schedules, meals and transportation to practices and games, she said.

 
Soccer players filled the room. Photo by Waldemar Borrero
Soccer players filled the room.
Photo by Waldemar Borrero
 
 
 

A longer drive to different fields and splitting the program among multiple locations could prevent some children from participating.

She urged commissioners to meet with league officials before making decisions about the property's future.
 

"Our league leadership is ready to sit down with you and talk with what it will take to keep these fields available for our youth," Lundry said.

Toby Lenz, who has volunteered as a soccer coach for more than 10 years and served as the recreational program director for the past three, said scattering teams across city parks would create operational problems.
 

Many alternative fields lack adequate lighting, parking or sufficient space to accommodate the program, he said.

Keeping teams together also allows coaches, referees and volunteers to supervise activities and respond to problems.
 

"Scattering our program across multiple city parks is not a practical substitute for a centralized soccer facility," Lenz said.

He reminded commissioners that the city had previously identified Ybor Alvarez as its second-highest capital priority, behind seawall construction.
 

"We're not asking the city to solve this problem alone," Lenz said. "We're asking you to remain a partner in finding a solution."

The possible loss of the soccer fields also drew concern from representatives of other youth sports programs.
 

Jackie D'Amico, director of the girls' Hammerhead recreational lacrosse program and head coach of the new Fernandina Beach High School girls' lacrosse team, said Hickory Street Park is already heavily used.

 
Jackie D'Amico
Jackie D'Amico
 
 
Girls' lacrosse shares the fields with boys' lacrosse, youth football and school soccer programs.
 

If Amelia Island youth soccer is forced to relocate there, she warned, the result could be reduced opportunities for other sports.

"Finding a solution for one youth sports program should not come at the expense of others," D'Amico said.
 

"We should not have to choose which children get the opportunity to play."

 

D'Amico also described how the local soccer program helped her own children establish friendships after her family moved to Fernandina Beach.

Her older son, she said, has remained involved as a youth coach and referee after aging out of competitive soccer.
 

Yvonne Klein, a longtime resident whose children play soccer, urged commissioners to consider using available impact fees along with the county's contribution.

Klein questioned whether the financial consequences of Amendment 3 should prevent the city from pursuing the purchase.
 

She said recreational facilities are an appropriate use of funds intended to accommodate community growth.

Richard Bernard, who said he has coached soccer at several levels, including Major League Soccer, described the importance of having a common home for youth athletics.
 

He warned that scattering teams among different locations would diminish the sense of community that develops when parents, players and coaches gather at one facility.

Joel Painter, a soccer parent, praised the dedication of Francis and the program's volunteers, urging commissioners to preserve the opportunity for local children to participate.
 

Dr. Vitas Dumasius, a Crane Island resident and father of three, said his family chose to live in the area partly because of the recreational opportunities available to children.

He also expressed concern about the possible effects of future airport development on nearby wildlife, including bald eagles nesting near his home.
 

Jason Stoddard, a Fernandina Beach resident and father of four who described nearly 20 years of aviation experience, acknowledged the need for long-term airport planning but urged commissioners to give equal consideration to youth recreation.

Stoddard said his family had lived in several states before moving to Fernandina Beach and found a strong sense of community through local youth sports.
 

"At Ybor Alvarez, they have somewhere they want to go," he said of the children.

He warned that the soccer club believes it could lose access to the fields after spring 2027 and asked the commission to reopen discussions with Nassau County about a joint purchase.
 

He also requested a public timeline for resolving the issue.

"These fields represent more than a place to play soccer," Stoddard said. "They're an invaluable gathering place for local families."
 

The uncertainty stems from the property's status as federally obligated airport land. Although the city has allowed recreational use for decades, the FAA must approve a long-term nonaviation lease or release the property from airport obligations before a sale can proceed.

The city's previous discussions focused on purchasing the portion of Ybor Alvarez occupied by the existing soccer fields while preserving other airport property for potential aviation development.
 

The FAA has not agreed to release the land.

Tuesday's discussion did not authorize a purchase or secure state funding. It placed recreational land acquisition among the city's proposed legislative priorities and left the FAA approval process unresolved.
 

The next step comes Dec. 1, when commissioners are scheduled to review the completed appraisals and consider whether to proceed with an FAA application.

Comments

2 comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

  • Mouton

    I will say for at least the 20th time, the FAA’s claim regarding the alleged indenture on that part of the property is baseless. The indenture on the personal property ie the runways and buildings as part of the entire airport land was effective for the depreciated life of the property, not in perpetuity. Furthermore there was never any use of that part of the property for any flying activity. This matter has been challenged elsewhere on the basis that there was no transfer if the city cannot do what it wants with the unencumbered land.

    If the FAA does not wish to abide by the terms of the original transfer, challenge in court. Also amend the current “development” plan to show no development beyond the current runway and building area is being proposed. That is of course if the city does not want this concrete poured and the open spaces, recreational area, destroyed over some illision of losing income. The city loses nothing as income generated at the AP must be used to augment airport activities, destroying more of the island.

    5 hours ago Report this

  • Martbrut

    It seems like our City Commission can find money for other pet projects. In the new park on the River, they made sure to create space for Petanaque courts that are barely used. They used funds to build pickleball ball courts at the City Park. They are spending $1.2M for Seaside Park improvements. Does it really need that much improvement? If they looked at priorities that citizens are asking for, I’m sure they could find a way to get this done.

    3 hours ago Report this