Amelia River Wharf project gets a new look, but city still has concerns

Posted

FERNANDINA BEACH — A revised design for the proposed Amelia River Wharf development on North Front Street will go before the Historic District Council on Thursday with new architectural details intended to address concerns about how the large commercial project would fit into the city's historic working waterfront.

 

The latest plans introduce changes to the building's exterior finishes, materials and architectural features, along with new illustrations showing the development from the waterfront and surrounding streets.

But a city staff report prepared for Thursday's meeting says the developer has not demonstrated compliance with several conditions imposed when the council granted conceptual approval in September, including restrictions on rooftop structures and the proposed observation tower.
 

The project, proposed by Compass Group Development on behalf of the property owners, would occupy vacant waterfront property at 0 North Front Street, adjacent north of the city's marina. It includes approximately 28,000 square feet of covered space for restaurants, retail shops and marina-related services, along with a boardwalk, parking and the possibility of a future marina.

Developer Ron Flick is seeking revised conceptual approval rather than final approval. The council's decision Thursday will determine whether the latest submission satisfies additional requirements imposed during the project's earlier reviews.
 

The most significant changes are to the building's appearance.

New architectural renderings prepared by Studio Z Architecture show a combination of cream-colored siding, darker board-and-batten surfaces, metal roofs, decorative brackets and railings, and wood accents. The proposed exterior palette includes charcoal, beige and gray, with bronze accents.
 

The updated design retains a prominent observation tower, multiple gabled rooflines and waterfront dining terraces. The building would stand above an elevated waterfront boardwalk, with access to potential future boat docks.

The revisions respond to criticism during the council's Sept. 17 meeting that the earlier design did not sufficiently resemble Fernandina Beach's historic waterfront architecture.
 

Council members had called for more southeastern coastal and industrial design elements consistent with the city's working waterfront, rather than an appearance they considered out of character with the surrounding area.

The new drawings also include street-level perspectives and views showing the building's relationship to nearby development, which council members requested to better judge its scale and appearance.
 

City planning staff acknowledged those changes.

 
Revised building design view from Front Street
Revised building design view from Front Street
 
 
"The applicant has made changes to the finishes, materials, and other cosmetic aspects of the project to comply with this condition," the staff report says.
 

Staff also concluded that the new context renderings and elevations satisfy the council's requirement for illustrations showing how the development would fit into the surrounding downtown landscape.

The report cautions, however, that the aerial renderings do not accurately depict Fernandina's downtown, although they communicate the general scale of the proposed buildings.
 

Public access to the riverfront remains another issue for the council.

The revised illustrations show pedestrian connections between Front Street and the waterfront, but planning staff says a more detailed circulation plan identifying pedestrian pathways is still needed.
 
The staff report specifically notes that the computer-enhanced renderings make it difficult to determine how pedestrians would move through the southern portion of the property.
 

The plans provide for public access along both sides of the development and through its center. Preserving public views of the Amelia River was among the conditions attached to the September approval.

The observation tower also remains a point of concern.
 

During the September meeting, council members questioned whether the tower could qualify for an exception to the waterfront's 30-foot building height limit. The staff report says the lookout structure extends 19 feet above that limit, although city staff has determined that the tower and rooftop mechanical screening qualify as permissible exceptions under the Community Redevelopment Area design guidelines.

The council's September approval restricted the tower to use as a viewing area, with no permanent habitable uses. Planning staff says the developer has not submitted changes demonstrating compliance with that condition and recommends documenting the restriction in a formal letter accompanying the approval and development order.
 

Staff also found no new plans demonstrating compliance with requirements to minimize rooftop mechanical enclosures and portions of the main roof that could exceed the height limit.

The project has undergone several reviews since June. The council considered the proposal that month and again in August, when a tie vote prevented a decision. In September, members unanimously approved the conceptual design subject to conditions addressing building height, architectural character, public access and the observation tower.
 

The November submission is intended to demonstrate progress toward satisfying those requirements before the developer prepares final architectural and engineering plans.

City staff is recommending revised conceptual approval, removing the previously imposed condition requiring additional north and south pedestrian context images because those have now been supplied. The remaining conditions would stay in place.
 

The development would still need final Historic District Council approval, a formal Technical Review Committee review and permits from applicable agencies before the city could issue a local development order.

 
City staff was critical of the inaccurate rendition of the building and the historic downtown.
City staff was critical of the inaccurate rendition of the building and the historic downtown.
 
 
 
 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here