Nature's Reflection

Know the rules before reeling in a shark in Florida

Posted

In October 2026, a New York man was arrested and charged with illegally catching a protected white shark off Cape Cod and dragging it onto a beach. Authorities were alerted after the man posted a video and photo of the captured shark on social media. The professional angler was charged with animal cruelty to a shark, fishing for a shark, mechanical deployment of bait using a drone, attempting to capture a shark, and unauthorized possession of a prohibited species. Bail was set at $10,000, and he was ordered to surrender his Massachusetts fishing license. The 9 1/2-foot male Atlantic white shark is named “Aaron the Shark” and was tagged by researchers in 2024.

On Amelia Island, Florida, shark fishing is popular on local beaches, where anglers enjoy the challenge of fighting a fish as big as a shark. I have personally seen a tiger shark brought in near Seaside park after a kayak angler dropped bait offshore. I have also witnessed a sandbar shark caught off the Amelia by the Sea private pier. Both sharks were brought onshore, out of the water. Recently, I have seen social media posts from local anglers proudly photographing themselves with large sharks on or near the shore.

So what are the shark fishing regulations in Florida?

Florida enacted stricter, more comprehensive shark fishing regulations in 2019. To legally fish for sharks in Florida, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) requires anyone 16 or older to complete the free Shark-Smart Fishing educational course before obtaining a shore-based shark fishing permit alongside a shore-based saltwater fishing license.

In Florida, 44 shark species are regulated, 29 of which are protected. The prohibited shark list includes great hammerhead, tiger, great white, whale shark, lemon, sandbar, oceanic whitetip and mako, among others. It is unlawful to harvest, possess, land, purchase, sell or exchange these species either from shore or a vessel. These sharks must remain in the water with their gills submerged and be released immediately without delay.

The second group includes Atlantic sharpnose, blacknose, blacktip, bonnethead, smooth dogfish and Florida smoothhounds, among others. These sharks are legal to harvest with a bag limit of one shark per person per day or a maximum of two per vessel. They must be kept whole until landed.

The third group includes shark species such as blue, bull, nurse, common thresher and spinner sharks. These are harvestable only if the fork length is at least 54 inches, also with a bag limit of one per person and two per vessel.

Anglers may catch a shark accidentally when shore-fishing for smaller fish, but those specifically fishing for sharks must take the shark fishing course and have a shore-based shark fishing permit. How does the FWC know if someone is fishing for sharks? Anglers who target sharks use much stronger gear and may deploy their bait with kayaks or drones using large hooks. This use of equipment meant to catch sharks triggers the requirement for a shore-based shark fishing permit.

The Smart-Shark Fishing course aims to educate anglers on how to release prohibited species without harm. The long struggle that sharks endure while being reeled in is life-threatening, and their odds of survival are low. They are fighting for their lives, being dragged in by a large hook in their mouths for an extended period. Adrenaline from the fight depletes a shark’s oxygen, and the psychological stress can kill it, even if it swims away looking healthy. Additionally, bringing sharks onto the beach for any length of time can damage their internal organs.

Fish, including sharks, are among the most heavily exploited and least protected animals on Earth, facing massive over-harvesting, habitat destruction, and a general lack of welfare laws. I personally think catch-and-release fishing borders on cruelty because humans are not taking the fish for food; they are just entertaining themselves with the fight, which causes serious physical and psychological damage to the fish. Fish are the only animals on the planet we treat this way. It is curious that they alone seem to muster little mercy from humans.

Florida is the world’s fishing capital with more fishing licenses than anywhere else and is taking progressive steps to protect sharks in the state’s waters. If you observe anglers catching a shark you believe is illegal, you can report it to FWC by calling 888-404-3922 or #FWC or *FWC from a cellphone.

Comments

1 comment on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

  • Mark Tomes

    All hunting and fishing, except for scientific population controls and survival (food), are recreational, occupational, or traditional, and hence are privileged. There's no inherent right to hunt or fish, and when such activities interfere with keeping a population of species healthy, it should be managed and controlled, and even stopped. We are all part of the web of life, the web of the universe, and every species has the right to thrive, same as humans.

    2 hours ago Report this